Interferometric observations and modeling of exo-cometary dust

Thesis defense of Philippe Priolet - Thursday, November 19th at 3.00 pm - Manuel Forestini room IPAG

Exozodiacal clouds (or exodis) are populations of hot or warm dust grains in the inner regions of exoplanetary systems. Over the past two decades, near-infrared interferometric surveys have shown that hot dust is relatively common around nearby AFGK stars, with a detection rate of approximately 20%, independent of stellar age. Radiative-transfer models indicate that the hot dust is typically composed of very small, micron- to sub-micron-sized grains located close to the sublimation radius. However, this region constitutes a particularly hostile environment for such particles. Radiation pressure can rapidly expel these grains from the system, while sublimation destroys grains on timescales far shorter than the ages of the host stars. Exozodi emission is also very faint ( 1% of the total flux) and compact, requiring at the same time high angular resolution and good sensitivity to detect and characterize them. Understanding these systems therefore requires not only accurate theoretical models of the dust, but also a careful understanding of what can actually be constrained from the observations.
During my PhD I therefore developed a rich self-consistent framework to model near- and mid-infrared interferometric, also called optical interferometry, observations of such dust populations. It has three main parts: (1) Understanding the data and its limitations, (2) extracting spatial information from said data and finally (3) developing a radiative transfer framework to model the spectral behaviour of such grains.
First I developed the first method to estimate the covariance matrix of squared visibilities based on data obtained with the VLTI/MATISSE instrument (3.2-12 μm). In principle the method could be applied to any interferometer, regardless of data reduction strategy. The resulting MATISSE covariance matrices reveal a complex structure with very strong correlations between spectral channels and significant correlations between baselines. Finally, I show how ignoring these correlations strongly biases inferred parameters for hot dust observations and underestimates their uncertainties.
I then applied this framework to MATISSE L-band (3.2-3.9 μm) observations of the iconic planetary system β Pictoris. The data reveal the presence of a significant circumstellar excess and when I include the full covariance matrix, geometric models favour compact emission at approximately 0.05 au from the star, very close to the expected dust sublimation region. The emission is highly inclined and its position angle is misaligned by about 60° with respect to the outer debris disk. The spectral slope of the circumstellar flux across the 3.2–3.6 μm range is consistent with emission dominated by submicron grains. These results provide the first direct evidence for the long-standing prediction of SED models: hot exozodiacal dust is concentrated close to the sublimation region and composed of submicron sized grains.
Finally, I developed pyGRaTer, an open-source 3D radiative transfer code for optically thin dust disks. The code self consistently calculates grain temperatures from their optical properties and models thermal emission and scattered light, finally it produces both spectral energy distributions and synthetic images from three-dimensional density distributions. I then used this code to model the inner regions of two extreme debris disks: HD113766 and HD172555. The preliminary results hint that the observed emission with PIONIER, MATISSE and GRAVITY (in the H, K, L, M-bands) might be the scattered light by the already known dust grain population detected in thermal emission in previous studies.
Together, this work sets a new framework for extracting the physical properties of faint inner hot dust populations which requires both accurate estimations of interferometric data statistics and models capable of exploiting the rich spatial and spectral information present in current and future data.

Thesis direction

  • Jean-Charles Augereau & Julien Milly

Examination committee:

  • Aurore Bacmann, Astronomer, IPAG UGA, Examiner
  • Bertrand Mennesson, Senior researcher, Nasa Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Examiner
  • Quentin Kral, Associate Astronomer, Observatoire de Paris, Examiner
  • Christine Chen, Astronomer, Space Telescope Science Institute, Referee
  • Sylvestre Lacour, Senior researcher, LIRA CNRS, Referee